NATIONAL ACTION PLAN of TURKEY
IMPLEMENTATIONS and FOLLOW-UP of the CONCLUSIONS of the UNITED NATIONS 4th WORLD CONFERENCE on WOMEN
Republic of Turkey, Prime Ministry, Directorate General on the Status and Problems of Women - 1997
TURKEY'S COMMITMENTS ON THE 4TH WORLD CONFERENCE ON WOMEN
WOMEN IN POWER AND DECISION-MAKING
INSTITUTIONAL MECHANISMS FOR THE ADVANCEMENT OF WOMEN
The 20th century has been an era in which women have gained more rights in legal, political, economic and cultural fields. However, women in many parts of the world are still fighting to obtain them.
In recent years, women have been actively trying to establish equality between men and women and obtain women's human rights. The basic obstacles preventing women from achieving human rights are the gender discrepancies in culture, religion, customs and traditions. In Turkey, women are aware that their country is a democratic, secular and developing country, and they are increasingly gaining access to education and health services. However, they also realize that there is a long and difficult struggle ahead before true equality with men can be obtained.
From the beginning of this century, noticeable progress within the Turkish Women's Movement concerning women's human rights has been recorded. Between the beginning of the century and today, the most important improvements for women in our country have evolved in the areas of women's human rights and women's position in society. It is most probable that Turkey is one of the countries where women's human rights are improving most rapidly and in a satisfactory way.
After I980, Turkey began an economic restructuralization process and implemented new policies for foreign trade and production. Increased integration with the outside world and the appearing of suitable production techniques, privatization, rapid population growth, urbanization, high inflation, decrease in public revenues including taxes and increase in public debts were the main characteristics of this period. These developments within the economy resulted in increased unemployment, a receding social security system, accelerated break in the agricultural society, growing employment in the informal sector, which affected women directly and created even greater hardship.
Turkey is among the countries which signed The Beijing Declaration and The Platform for Action without any reservations. The main goal of this Declaration, which is designed to improve living conditions globally and give peace to mankind, is equality between men and women.
Although women's rights have improved in our country, we are aware of the fact that in certain areas like education, health, employment and participation in political life, we have not yet reached a satisfactory result.
Due to this, Turkey has made a commitment to remove it reservations stated in the Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women at the 4th World Conference on Women and emphasized that solving the problems of women in the areas of education and health is Turkey's primary goal. According to these commitments, by the year 2000 the literacy rate of women will be increased by 100% and mother and child mortality will be decreased by 50%. In order to remove the reservations from the Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women, changes have to be made regarding the discriminatory items in The Civil and Penal Codes. For the amendments in the Civil Code, a draft has been prepared by the State Ministry Responsible for Women and Family Affairs and has been sent to the Turkish Grand National Assembly.
Other priorities for Turkey, as urgent as its previous commitments, are to strengthen the national mechanism for the advancement of women, fight violence against women and integrate the gender perspective into all public policies and programs.
During the last two years since the 4th World Conference on Women in 1995, there has been an increased public awareness about, and especially among, women. However there is a need for men to obtain the same awareness.
Women are aware that the implementation of the Platform for Action will improve their lives, so they are fighting for its realization. Currently special events concerning women like Women's Day, No to Violence Against Women's Day, and the Anniversary of the Turkish Women's Political Rights are being celebrated with more enthusiasm and participation.
Turkey's National Action Plan was prepared between 19-20 December 1996 in accordance with the Beijing spirit and in the light of the 4th World Conference on Women with the greatest possible participation of state institutions and organizations, women's organizations, political parties, unions, professional associations and media coordinated by the Directorate General on the Status and Problems of Women and edited by a committee formed by the Prime Ministry Housing Development Administration, the State Institute of Statistics, the Directorate General on the Status and Problems of Women, Women’s S Foundation, and the Contemporary lawyers Association.
In order to realize the Action Plan, the participants and concerned parties must take part in this effort. Only this way can living conditions for women be improved. I would like to take this opportunity to thank especially the employees of the Directorate General on the Status and Problems of Women and everyone who contributed to the design of this plan, and I invite all concerned to cooperate in the implementation of this Action Plan.
Isilay SAYGIN
State Minister
I. EDUCATION AND TRAINING OF WOMEN
In our country there are no laws prohibiting girls from attending pre-school, general, technical-vocational training and higher education. However, between the country's rural and urban regions, between geographical regions and the cities' various sections, there is a difference in attendance between girls and boys depending on the level of development.
Since the foundation of the Republic, primary education has been compulsory in Turkey, and in 1990, 30.7% of the female population and 10.1% of the male population were illiterate.
Until 1997 the compulsory education period was five years, and the enrollment rate during this period was virtually equal for boys and girls. During the 1994-95 school year the rate for girls was 88.6% and 92.6% for boys. However, in higher education, the gap between girls and boys widens, and girls are the disadvantaged group. For example, during the 1994-95 school year, the percentage of girls who attended secondary education was 59.1% and 78.2% for boys. In Turkey, formal education encompasses general, vocational and technical education institutes where a minimum of three years of schooling is required after primary education. In the 1994-95 school year, in general secondary and high schools, the percentage of girl students was 40.1%, and in technical-vocational secondary and high schools it was 38.1%.
The technical and vocational education which is designed to prepare students for the requirements of the labor market and to direct them towards employment and income generating activities is far from achieving its goal as far as girls are concerned. Girls who had newly enrolled in the technical secondary and high schools in the 1990-91 school year constituted 26% of the girls who newly enrolled in the vocational-technical secondary and high schools, and the percentage of the ones newly enrolled in religious education schools -which is a part of the technical-vocational education - was 32.3%. In the 1994-95 school year girls' enrolment in technical education decreased to 25.6%, whereas it increased to 41.8% in the religious education schools. The enrollment ratio for girls in the 1990-91 school year for the vocational schools, which are offering education programs in areas such as commerce, tourism, health care, agriculture, law and fine arts, was 41.7% and in 1994-95 it dropped to 32.6%. Particularly in the region of Southeast Anatolia, both the schooling rate and the number of female teachers working in the village schools are gradually decreasing. But it is obvious that having female teachers working in areas which are not quite economically developed and where traditional values are prevailing is extremely important for the education of girls.
Although women's participation in higher education has shown an increase over the years, there is still great disparity between women and men. In the 1994-95 school year, the ratio of female students enrolled in university education increased to 38.4%.
According to 1994-95 data, the participation percentages of women studying at universities are: home economics 80%, medicine and health professions 64%, communication and documentation 62%, commerce, fine arts and industrial programs 55%, natural sciences 45%, social sciences 37%, and engineering 20%.
During the last ten years, the biggest increase in women's participation in higher education has been in areas where women are already concentrated, such as social sciences, fine arts and education. However, although they are not traditional subjects, women's participation in commerce and business administration has also increased extensively.
Also, in engineering, which is not considered a typical female occupation, the percentage of girl students increased from 18.7% in 1982-83 to 24% in 1992 - 93. But this increase can be explained by the presence of different departments within the general category of engineering. For example, in architecture and city planning departments, the share of female students was 50% the same year.
Compulsory education, which was five years till July 1997, has been changed, and the Primary Education and Training Law which has been approved, extended it to eight year's and was published in the Official Gazette Nr. 23084, dated 18 August 1997, and is currently in force. Thus the implementation started with the 1997-98 school year. The eight-year compulsory education will have a great impact on the schooling of young girls.
The Ministry of National Education has various informal training and education programs for young girls and women who have never enrolled in formal education or who left school prematurely. For girls who 1eft school for various reasons and for women, there are opportunities to learn income generating skills, and they are also encouraged to establish cooperatives.
The project which is to be implemented by the Ministry of National Education called "Improvement of Young Girls and Women's Education" will be a very important tool to solve the adult illiteracy problem. This project includes opening reading and writing courses for those in the 7-I4 age group who are not attending formal schools and for illiterate individuals above 14 years of age. Furthermore, for those who are literate but without a certificate, second grade courses will be opened.
"Vocational and Technical Education Development Project" (VTEDP) includes a new restructuralization in vocational and technical education institutes, and according to the modular education system, formal and informal education curricula are implemented in an integrated way. In this education model, girls who attended formal education but left it at an early stage will be given an employment opportunity with a certificate according to the module in which they trained. Furthermore, women who are not able to attend formal education for various reasons are allowed to choose modules and obtain a certificate according to their own level.
The Ministry of National Education has also started an open high school project which began in the 1994-95 school year, and it will ensure an important educational opportunity for girls who left school without completing their education and for women of all ages.
B. Turkey's Commitments on the 4th World Conference on Women
Education and Training of Women
Objective: Ensure women to have an equal share with men in formal and informal education
By Government;
- These courses, alongside vocational information, should include basic information like how to read and write, health care, family planning, and nutrition.
By Government and non-governmental organizations;
- Eliminate the social and cultural barriers which impede women's participation in formal and informal education and form a public opinion to eradicate the prevailing religious pressures.
- Remove legislative regulations which are discriminatory and which reinforce social and cultural barriers.
Objective: Remove the discriminatory elements from educational materials.
By Government and non-governmental organizations;
- Cooperate with the Ministry of National Education to utilize non-discriminatory educational material in in-service training for educators and implementers, and ensure their assimilation of the subject.
Objective: Increase women's literacy rate to 100%
By Government and non-governmental organizations;
Objective: Provide environmental education for women
By Government and non-governmental organizations;
In order to raise women's awareness on environmental issues, incorporate the subject in all education programs, ensure women's participation in environmental decision-making at all levels, emphasize the importance of women's role as consumers in safeguarding the environment.
Objective: Provide political education for women
By Government and non-governmental organizations;
Restructure the already existing leadership education programs provided by non-governmental organizations and universities with a feminist view, or design new programs to encourage women to enter politics.
In 1995 our country ratified the Convention on the Rights of the Child. The Social Services and Save the Children Society have the power and authority to implement the Convention. Our country's laws do not discriminate between girls and boys in education, health care or when participating in social and cultural activities. However, traditional values and attitudes are prioritizing the boys in all areas, especially in education.
The most common problem in our country is the young girls' early drop-out from school in the rural regions. In the urban regions, 86.3% of girls aged 6-14, continue their education, and in the rural regions 78.6%. At the primary level, the rate of young girls who dropped out of school was 02.58% in urban areas, and 05.40% in the rural regions. The fundamental reason why young girls are removed from school is their reaching puberty. Furthermore, young girls from families which have migrated to the cities are expected to contribute to the family income and help with domestic chores. Yet another reason is that the girls are often married off at an early age. Working girl children belong to families where 55% of the heads of the household are female, and of those, 94% have primary school education or less. This explains why the children are made to help improve the household income and share the domestic responsibilities. Although the attendance at the primary level is virtually equal to girls and boys, at the secondary level the gap between boys and girls widens.
With reference to the preparatory works in June 1995, a meeting was held by DGSPW for the 4th World Conference on Women titled 'Essential Policies for Women'. Regarding girl children, it was decided to create equal opportunities in education, encourage girls who dropped out early from school to participate in formal vocational education, and direct girls towards non-traditional areas like computer science and tourism. Those are the most essential policies.
Within the context of the essential policies for women regarding the 4th World Conference on Women, the priorities are girl children, the low income urban families, the newly migrated population, and the rural communities which tend to urbanize.
B. Turkey's Commitments on the 4th World Conference on Women
The Girl-Child
Objective: Eliminate discrimination against girls in education and training
By Government and non-governmental organizations;
Objective: Eradicate negative cultural attitudes and practices against the girl child
By Government;
60% of the population in Turkey, including both girls and boys, is between 0-14 years of age, and 10 million women between 15-59 years of age constitute nearly 25% of the population. Since the majority of the population consists of women, inevitably their problems have a great impact on the country's social life.
Although life expectancy at birth is longer for women in our country, it is compared to the developed countries where both sexes benefit equally from health care services. It is estimated that from 1996, life expectancy at birth is 65.9 years for men and 70.5% for women.
In Turkey, although the fertility rate has decreased in recent years, it is still high and there is still a considerable discrepancy between different regions and between urban and rural parts of the country.
One of the important causes of the high fertility rate is the early marrying age. The average fertility rate per woman was 4.0 children in 1978, 3.0 in 1988, and 2.7 in 1993. Fertility specific to age is still concentrated in the younger age-group. The age-group of 20-24 has the highest fertility rate. In Turkey, 8% of 17- year olds, 15% of 18-year olds, and 23% of 19-year old girls either become mothers or become pregnant with their first child.
The fertility rate differs between regions. The Eastern Anatolia region has the highest fertility rate with 4.4 births per woman, and the Western Anatolia region has the lowest with 2.0 births per woman. Furthermore, the fertility rate differs between rural and urban districts. Women who are living in rural regions have approximately one more child than women living in urban regions.
In addition, the fertility rate differs according to women's education level. Uneducated women give birth to at least one more child than those who graduated from elementary school, and their birth rate is 2.5 more when compared to women who graduated from at least secondary school.
Women, particularly during their reproductive years, when compared to men of the same age, visit the doctor more often. However, in early childhood, boys are taken to the doctor more often than girls. When compared to developed countries, less medical visits occur in Turkey. The level of education is an important factor regarding the number of medical visits made, and women with higher education make up the group with the most visits.
In Turkey nearly 2000 women die every year from pregnancy-related causes either birth or in childbed. According to the 1989 data, maternal mortality was 132 per 100 000 live births. The statistics show that maternal mortality is due to: pregnancy and toxemia (41%), bleeding (I9.9%), infections (5.5%), other complications (25%), and unknown causes (8.6%). These are the causes which can be eradicated by prevention of risky and unwanted pregnancies.
During pregnancy, 62% of women receive assistance from trained health personnel. In more than half of the live births, prenatal care begins before the 5th month of pregnancy. Tetanus vaccination of pregnant women is still quite insufficient. 16% of pregnant women receive one dose; and 26% two or more doses of tetanus vaccination. According to the 1993 Turkish Population Health Research (TPHR), 60% of births took place in health institutions. However, it is estimated that home births occur without the help of trained health personnel.
Two-thirds of the pregnant women and half of the non-pregnant have iron deficiency and are anemic.
According to the Health Ministry data, from October 1985 to the end of November 1996, a total of 600 people were infected with HIV/AIDS. Among those, there were 218 cases of AIDS, and 382 were HIV positive. Since 1985, the infection trend shows a slow but continuous increase. In Turkey, more than 1/3 of HIV infections were transmitted by heterosexual sexual relations.
According to the Population Planning Law Nr.2827 dated 1965 and updated in 1983 education, training and services of family planning is conducted by the Health Ministry.
In Turkey, according to TPHR data of 1993, 63o/o of married couples are using contraceptives. 35% of all the couples are using a modern family planning method, while 28% of them are using the traditional methods.
The use of modern methods is related to the level of education and differs between settlement areas and regions.
The abortion rate decreased slightly from 1990 until today. It is observed that this decrease is related to the number of wanted abortions rather than the spontaneous ones. In 1992, the number of wanted abortions was 18 in every 100 pregnancies. The abortion rate differs between regions.
In spite of the important reduction in recent years, infant and child mortality rates are still not at the desired levels. Child survival is closely linked to the spacing and timing of births, the mother's age and her education level. The infant mortality rate of uneducated women is 1.6 times more than that of mothers who have at least graduated from elementary school.
The infant mortality rate is highest for infants born after closely-spaced pregnancies (where the time between two pregnancies is less than two years). The mortality rate of this group is 3.2 times higher than that for infants born 4 or more years apart.
B. Turkey’s Commitments on the 4th World Conference on Women
Women and Health
Objective : Increase women's access throughout the life cycle to appropriate, affordable and quality health care, information, and related services
By Government :
By Governments; private health institutions and non-governmental organizations :
Objective : Develop preventive programs to improve women's health
By Government :
By Government, private health care institutions and non-governmental organizations:
Objective : Undertake gender sensitive initiatives concerning sexually transmitted diseases, HIV/AIDS, sexual health and reproductive health
By Government, private health care institutions and non-governmental organizations :
Objective : Promote information and research about women's health
By Government, private health care institutions and non-governmental organizations :
Objective : Increase resources and monitor follow-up for women's health
By Government;
By Government, private health care institutions and non-governmental organizations;
Establish cooperation and coordination between all the sectors involved in women’s health and which provide services for them.
Objective: Eliminate and prevent social attitudes, legal and regulatory practices which harm women's health
By Government;
Provide in-service training for the health personnel to address the physical and psychological problems due to domestic violence within the existing health care system.
By Government, private health care institutions and non-governmental organizations;
Provide education opportunities and continuous information to the public in order to ensure the fulfillment of the above mentioned objectives.
Violence against women is a physical, sexual, and psychological reality which is committed and often concealed in private and public spheres by individuals and/or states.
The extent of the violence against women, which is a violation of human rights, is unknown. Before 1980, the women's movement put the debate about violence against women on Turkey's agenda and, since then the problem has received greater attention through debates, conferences, and similar activities.
In 1991, for the first time in Turkey, a local municipality entered a cooperation with a non-governmental organization, the Women's Solidarity Foundation. The result of this cooperation was
the establishment of the Altýndað Women's Solidarity Center. This center provides psychological and legal assistance to the applicants. The Women's Solidarity Foundation also opened the first independent Woman Shelter in 1993. The aim of the shelter is to give support and help women to provide for themselves and to make their own decisions in a secure environment, especially for the victims of domestic violence. Between 1991 and 1996, more than 1000 women applied to the center.The Purple Roof Women's Shelter Foundation was established in 1990 and opened the Women's Counseling Center and the Women's Shelter. Purple Roof provides psychological and legal assistance, employment guidance, give required sheltering, vocational training and courses for income generating skills.
Also, the Istanbul Women's Rights Commission and the Turkish Women Jurists Association provides legal assistance in the Istanbul area for women who are victims of violence.
The Directorate General on the Status and Problems of Women (DGSPW) supports research about violence against women and the educational programs for the various public and private sector workers.
The Information and Application Bank (IAB) has been established within the DGSPW to offer guidance and counseling services on prevention of violence against women, legal procedures, entrepreneurship and help in marketing handicrafts. By the end of 1996, 1647 women had applied to the IAB. Of the applicants, 316 sought legal advice about domestic violence, 119 needed psychological counseling, and 52 women asked for sheltering.
The Women's Commission of the Contemporary Lawyers Association provides free lega1 advice and assistance in all the branches of DGSPW, with the cooperation of IAB, and follows all court cases of violence against women free of charge.
Furthermore, the General Directorate of Social Services and Protection of Children (GDSSPC) has women's hostels in Ýzmir, Bursa, Antalya, Ankara, Eskiþehir and Ýstanbul with a total capacity of 130 women. The hostels offer shelter to t
hose who are "abandoned by their spouses due to family disputes; physically, sexually or psychologically abused; subject to material or social poverty beyond their control caused by their personal or environmental conditions; forced into an unwanted marriage; have recently been released from prison: have illegitimate children and have been refused by their families for this reason". GDSSPC Women's Hostels opened in 1991 and by the end of October 1997, 1472 women accompanied by 1301 children were admitted to the hostels, and employment was provided for 189 of the employment-seeking women.The Women's Counseling Center of Bornova municipality was established in 1991 in Ýzmir. The center provides psychological and legal assistance and helps find employment for
the admitted women.Küçükçekmece Women's Home was established by Küçükçekmece municipality in Ýstanbul in 1996 and offers services for victims of violence. Between 7 March 1996 and June 1996, 55 women were admitted, and 47 of them, accompanied by 15 childr
en, were sheltered.The Crisis Intervention Center of Ankara University Medical Faculty also offers treatment for people older than 15 who have had and are having psychosomatic symptoms due to daily life problems. The patients who are being sent to the center generally do not have any complaints about domestic violence. However, for the majority of the women, domestic violence is the underlying cause for the symptoms.
B. Turkey's Commitments on the 4th World Conference on Women
Violence Against Women
Objective: Take integrated measures to prevent and eliminate violence against women
By Government and local governments;
By Government and non-governmental organizations;
Objective: Protect women from violence
By Government;
Issues stipulated in the Penal Code;
Issues not stipulated in the Penal Code;
By non-governmental organizations and professional associations;
Despite the consensus that women's participation in the labor force has great importance for themselves, for the family, and the national development, their participation rate in the labor force is still low and continuously decreasing. One of the reasons for this decrease is that, although the labor law gives equal rights, the necessary mechanisms for providing vocational and technical training which will make women qualified and help them find employment have not been established. The participation rate which was 34% in October 1990 decreased to 30.1% in 1996. The participation rate of men, during the same period, also decreased from 75.3% to 70.2%. The majority of women who worked full time as unpaid family workers in the agricultural sector have been unable to find employment after migrating to the cities. The woman's role in the family, power relations and her position regarding decision-making are the facts affecting woman's participation in the urban labor force. Even if the education level and skills are equal for men and women, after migrating to the cities, men can more easily find employment, when compared to women. The reasons for these women not having employment in the cities are the family responsibilities, negative attitudes of close relatives, and social norms and values against women working outside the home. These factors decrease women's participation in the labor force both in rural and urban areas. The number of unemployed females over 12 years of age is 16 million, and 11.5 million (72%) of them are housewives.
Another factor which affects women's participation in the labor force is the education level. According to April 1996 data, women's participation rate in urban areas increases with the level of education, and for faculty and corresponding level graduates, the participation rate reaches 87.1%.
Women are employed intensively in the agricultural sector in Turkey. With men’s break from agriculture, their labor participation is decreasing, and because women are filling their places, women's participation rate in rural labor force is increasing. April 1996 data indicates that the rural employment rate for women working within the agricultural sector is 74.7% and for men it is 32.8%. Despite this increase, there is no improvement in the economical conditions for rural women, because 90.6% of them are unpaid family workers. The urban structure reflects negatively on women's employment opportunities. As mentioned before, immigrant women either become housewives or work within the informal sector, in marginal jobs without social security in the cities. The main employment available for urban females are unqualified, unregistered, marginal, and informal jobs.
Another intensive area for women is the service sector. The women's share in this sector is 15.8%, and some of the jobs in this sector are considered being appropriate because they are extensions of women's traditional roles. Due to the absence of policies and adequate support to direct women towards vocational or technical training, a qualified women’s labor force which will fill the requirements of the labor market can not be formed. These factors help the promotion and reproduction of stereotyped understanding of women, and they are directed towards occupations considered appropriate.
In the industrial sector, particularly in the manufacturing industry, women’s employment is still quite limited. In this sector, women are always preferred for labor-intensive jobs.
Women and children workers are preferred by the industrial and service sectors because they are prepared to work for low salaries, can easily be prevented from becoming organized, and work in unhealthy conditions without having any social rights and security, especially in unregistered workplaces.
A review of the sectoral employment data (April 1996) indicates that 74.7% of women have agriculture-related professions, 6.1% have scientific-technical professions, whereas the rate drops to 0.9% in entrepreneurial, managerial, and high level executive positions.
Another big difference can be seen between employed men and women in the structure of employment. While the rate of employer/self-employed women is 7.7%, for men it is 38.2%. The share of unpaid family workers in female employment is 67.5% whilst it is 12.7% in male employment.
Turkey has great imbalance in the development levels among regions. Various projects were started in 1980 at national and international levels in order to eliminate the discrepancies among regions, creating solutions for the rural women's problems and integrating them into the development.
Women in workplaces connected to the Social Security Institute (SSI), BAÐ-KUR, a
nd the Pension Fund (PF) can enter the social security system. The majority of the paid workers in the industrial and service sectors are members of the social security system via SSI. SSI records for 1994 indicate that the total number of insured women was only 418,122. Thus, the insured women's share of the total insured was 9.95%. In BAÐ-KUR, which is the social security institution covering self-employed individuals, the total number of members was 2,700,398, and the number of women was only 254,258 (9.42%) in 1994. The Pension Fund, which is the social security institution that provides pension plans for civil servants has the highest proportion of women members. In 1994, the total number of members was 1,896,000 and the number of women was 715,585 (37.74%).After giving the outlines of female employment in Turkey, working women's problems can be summarized as follows:
Daily and weekly working hours are other obstacles that prevent women from combining family and working life. Flexible working patterns are suggested and are being discussed as a new lease on life for working women. Although, in the short run these suggestions might be positive for women's adjustment of working life to their family, these work patterns must be addressed with great caution since they can also mean a regression from already established rules and gained rights such as salary, social benefits, paid leave, social security, seniority, union membership, and collective agreement rights. If implemented priorities must be given to protect gained rights, voluntary pension schemes, and sabbatical leave, but instead of promoting flexible work patterns, it is preferable to discuss reducing the amount of daily and weekly working hours.
A work pattern which is becoming more common among women is piecework in their homes. This kind of work, which women do at home as self-employed or as paid workers for an employer, penetrates their family life, and the paid workers especially find themselves outside of the protectional environment of the workplace. They are not organized, working for low wages and these kinds of work patterns separate women from social communication and the public sphere. There are no adequate laws regulating and securing the quality and quantity of female labor performed in the homes.
There is also discrimination between men and women working as self-employed or paid workers concerning tax cuts, and especially against married women. Social rights which are gained by laws and collective agreements are limited when the woman is married.
Within the labor force, since female labor is regarded as second class and their income is seen as a small addition to the family budget, the women are the first and easiest to dismiss when pregnant and breast-feeding. Since the laws regulating employment security are inadequate, this has a great impact upon women as laborers. Employment security is the insurance for union rights and liberties. The lack of employment security for women who are already passive in this area results in estrangement from joining the unions and from being organized. According to 1997 statistics, the total number of union members was 2,774,622 of which 372,985 were women. Unemployment insurance is a great support for temporarily unemployed women, and for them the absence of this support is a big loss.
B. Turkey's Commitments on the 4th World Conference on Women
Women and the Economy
Objective: Eliminate occupational segregation and al1 forms of employment discrimination
By Government;
Objective: Increase female employment, protect working women, and promote women's economic rights and independence, including access to employment appropriate working conditions and control over economic resources
By Government;
Objective: Strengthen women's economical capacity and commercial networks
By Government;
Objective: Promote harmonization of work and family responsibilities for women and men
By Governments;
Objective: Make women's labor visible
By Government and non-governmental organizations;
VI. WOMEN IN POWER AND DECISION-MAKING
Although Article 10 of the Constitution of the Republic of Turkey states that citizens cannot be discriminated against on the basis of gender, there is no specific article stating that women and men have equal rights. Instead, in practice, Article 10 is interpreted as giving women and men equal rights and is considered to be in accordance with the Constitution’s general equality principle.
In our country, every five years a five-year development plan is prepared for the government's implementation, and in the fifth of the five-year plans (1985-1990) for the first time women's issues, and policies to be followed up and measures to be taken on this subject were included as a separate section.
In the chapter "Legislative and Administrative Arrangements" of the seventh five-year development plan, it is anticipated that the discriminatory items in the Turkish Civil Code, Penal Code, Labor Law and tax laws have to be changed to secure equality between men and women.
In the program of the 55th Government of the Republic of Turkey, which was established in July 1997, it is stated that importance will be given to the efforts which are directed towards eliminating negative conditions in order to maintain women's full participation in economic, social, cultural, and political life.
Turkish women were granted suffrage rights on 5 December 1934. However, due to disadvantaged positions of women in decision-making and power mechanisms, the improvement in the legal arena has not reflected itself in the social/political life. Although there is no difference between men and women using their voting rights, it is not possible to say that women are using their right to be elected as equally as men do.
When reviewing the last 100 years of Turkish society, it becomes obvious that the most meaningful changes have occurred in the social position of women but it is also a reality that women have many problems caused by the economical and social structures which have not yet been solved.
Although women are actively involved in working life and production, they do not get their deserved share. Their relative share can not be turned into capital due to patriarchal values. Women's main obstacle when entering politics is financial, such as being able to afford the "nominee fee", and having a budget to promote themselves. Women cannot escape the pressures of traditional-religious values, and due to lack of public support, family responsibilities like caring for children and the elderly fall upon them. This situation also helps to reinforce the idea that politics is mainly a male occupation.
The acceleration of the women's movement in the 1980's, raised women's political consciousness, encouraged women to participate in politics, and made political parties give greater importance to women.
One of the five parties having seats in the Turkish Grand National Assembly (TGNA) began implementing quotas in the 1980's and in their party program it is stated that "there must be at least 1/4 of the members from both sexes in the province and county assemblies and at the highest level of the party management", and two other parties gave a reduction of 50% of the "nominee fee" for women candidates in the 1995 general election.
In addition, the Constitution of 1982 prohibited parties from establishing branches for women and youth; however, this prohibition was removed by decree Nr. 4121 on 23.7.1995. The efforts to change the laws concerning this subject is on-going.
Even if women in politics can overcome financial difficulties, be aware of their constitutional rights, be highly educated, and have respected professions, there are still obstacles stemming from patriarchal culture, social structure and stereotyped political traditions, preventing women from taking their places in decision-making and power mechanisms.
During the 1935 general election, women for the first time could be elected to parliament. Of the 395 elected parliamentarians 18 were women and this was the highest rate (4.6%) ever recorded. After the 1946 election, women's participation in politics rapidly decreased due to the introduction of the multi-party system and changes in the political ideology.
During the last election on the 24th of December 1995, the number of women elected to parliament was higher than in previous elections. Of the 550 elected to the TGNA, 13 were women (2.4%).
Women's participation in local governments, which can be considered as a first step for women to enter politics, is also limited. In 1984, 0.3% of the 2,202 Provincial Assembly members were women. In 1989 and 1994, the percentage of women was 0.8% for both years of the 2,653 and 30,334 members, respectively.
While there were no women mayors elected in the 1984 election, in 1989 0.2% and in 1994 0.4% of the elected mayors were women.
When the 1984, 1989, and 1994 election results for local government are compared, they show that there was an increase in the ratio, but only for elected mayors and not in general. This is evidence that the above mentioned obstacles prevail.
University graduated women are mainly working in the public sector. But in decision-making positions, the number of women is very low. For example, the results of the 1994 Public Personnel Poll show that in managerial general services, the percentage of female public servants was 32.71%, whereas in health services it was 65.63%, and in education and training services 43.44%.
Until today only one woman governor has been appointed, and currently none of the 79 administrative provinces has a female governor. In Turkey the total of deputy district governors is 806, and only 3 of them are women. In addition, of the 118 deputy district governor candidates, 4 are women.
Despite de facto prevention which occurs in Turkey from time to time, the number of women judges and prosecutors is gradually increasing. The total of Turkey's judges and public prosecutors is 7,635 and 1,368 (18%) of them are women. The Council of State, which is an organ of the superior courts, is headed by a woman, and there are 16 women members of the Council of State. Furthermore, there are 23 women prosecutors and 65 administrative judges in the Council of State. The Court of Appeals has 13 women members and 2 of them are heads of departments, and there are 10 women prosecutors. In the Constitutional Court which has 15 active members, 11 are regular members and 4 substitutes. One of the regular and 2 of the substitute members are women.
In the Union of Turkish Bars, 9,202 of the 32,059 total registered lawyers, are women. The percentage of women lawyers is 29%. In Turkey there are 1,347 notaries, and 209 of them are women (15.5%).
There are 44,086 teaching professionals in the universities, and 33% of them are women. 20.5% of the professors, 29.3% of the associate professors, 26.7% of the assistant professors, 29.1% of the lecturers, 35.4% of the research assistants, and 56.5% of other teaching personnel are women.
In the Turkish Armed Forces, there is a total of 483 women officers and 4,654 women civil administrative personnel. The Armed Forces stopped recruiting female officers in 1960; however, in 1982 this practice was resumed.
Women in Turkey who are working in fields requiring specialization are concentrated especially in education, medicine, and law.
Although there are equal opportunities and equal rights for men and women to represent their country abroad, in practice the percent of women in the same status as men is lower. In 1992, of the total of 7,846 civil servants sent abroad, 6,402 were men, and l,444 (18.4%) were women.
Our country is developing very rapidly in every aspect of life, which includes working life where women's status is improving, and as mentioned above, women are stepping out of traditional patterns. Furthermore, women in decision-making positions, in the public sector are gradually increasing. In addition, the number of women in managerial positions within the private sector and professional organizations is also increasing.
Turkey also has women representatives in some of the international organizations: as Director of the Family and Reproductive Health Department, WHO, as Asia-Pacific Director of the United Nations Drug Control Program (UNDCP), as Deputy President of the Executive Committee of the International Research and Training Institute for the Advancement of Women. as Member of the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women, as Co-chair Person of European Council, and as Deputy President of NATO's Committee of Female Corps.
B. Turkey's Commitments on the 4th World Conference on Women
Participation in Power and Decision-making
Objective : Enact laws to strengthen women's participation in power structures and decision-making
By Government and non-governmental organizations;
Objective : Take measures to ensure women's equal access to and full participation in power structures and decision-making
By Government;
Objective : Ensure women's full participation to political life
By Government;
By Government, political parties and non-governmental organizations;
VII. INSTITUTIONAL MECHANISMS FOR THE ADVANCEMENT OF WOMEN
In accordance with the Convention on the Elimination of All Kinds of Discrimination Against Women, and in order to give Turkish women their rightful status in social, economical, cultural and political areas, the Directorate General on the Status and Problems of Women (DGSPW) was established as an institutional mechanism for the advancement of women within the Ministry of Labor and Social Security on 29.10.1990 with law nr. 3670. And on 24.06.1991 it was printed in the Official Gazette nr. 20911. The Directorate General continue its functions as an institution attached to the Prime Ministry.
Aims of the Directorate General are:
Duties of the Directorate General are:
In Turkey, the national statistics institute, the State Institution of Statistics (SIS)has been collecting and publishing all kinds of data related to human resources on a gender-differentiated basis since its foundation in 1927. Due to changes in context and methods, some of the data does not have continuity in time, although for the last 70 years data has been collected and published on main subjects like population, education, employment, etc.. with gender as the basic variable.
In 1990 SIS started a rearranging process with the already existing data from various fields to reflect women's position and problems. In order to accelerate this process and train technicians to become experts on this subject, SIS established the Social Structure and Women’s Statistics Department in 1993, and the same year it cooperated with the DGSPW in a foreign aided project to create a computerized database on women's statistics and indicators. Furthermore, SIS cooperates with institutions and organizations concerned with women’s issues to produce data by taking into account their demands and provides technical support for exterior statistical work.
After 1990, SIS published two books about women's statistics titled "Women’s Statistics,1927-1990’s" and "Statistics on Women, 1927-1992".
Data related to men's and women's participation in economic life is collected on the basis of institutions, public and private sectors since 1970 and on the basis of households since 1988.
The methodological part of a research which is designed to measure time use of housewives, their service production time, and time for voluntary activities has been completed, and implementation has begun in a pilot area.
Since 1994, the methodological work of collecting data about poverty and income distribution on the basis of gender is continuing.
Hacettepe Institute of Population Studies collects data on subjects such as the fertility rate in Turkey, infant and child mortality, pre-natal and post-natal care, family planning services, child health, etc., which is then being regionally grouped.
The intersectoral committee established in 1994 to improve the vital statistics recording system (recording of birth and death) is continuing the effort. The absence of data on the subject of morbidity will be restored by the project "Health Information System" which is implemented by the Health Ministry with the cooperation of relevant institutions.
Preparatory work has begun to collect data on violence against women.
B. Turkey's Commitments on the 4th World Conference on Women
Institutional Mechanisms for the Advancement of Women
Objective: Provide legal status for the Directorate General on the Status and Problems of Women
By Government;
- Supply documents to non-governmental organizations for their lobbying on this subject.
- Develop a new organization schedule for this objective.
- Allocate a sufficient budget to realize its objectives.
- Investigate and determine in which cities the provincial organizing of the DGSPW is most needed.
- Determine new staff requirements and sources of work force.
- Provide in-service training for the personnel appointed to the provincial organizations of the DGSPW.
- Establish an information and communication network to strengthen the DGSPW’s role as a coordinator by meetings, seminars, publications, etc.
- Develop a unit related to non-governmental organizations within the DGSPGW.
Objective : Implement the 297th paragraph of the Platform for Action
By Government;
- Form this Committee with the help of public institutions and organizations and especially with women oriented non-governmental organizations.
- Follow-up the commitments of the 4th World Conference on Women to ensure their implementation and publish periodical reports on the subject.
- Follow-up and monitor the efforts of the other countries which joined the Conference.
Objective: Generate gender-related statistics
By Government;
In today's societies, mass media reproduces social norms and values through news and comments. The patriarchal values dominating mass media reproduce stereotyped mages of women and despite the visible signs of change, it reinforces women's traditional roles. In reality, the new women's thoughts, beliefs and ways of realizing herself are not reflected in this process, with her own discourse.
In Turkey, women's image in the mass media is not differentiated and does not reflect women's point of view. For example, in programs involving violence, women are always shown as pitiful individuals or as victims. In 1993, the research "The Media, Violence and Women" on news involving violence printed in newspapers, showed that 15.2% of news about women subjected to violence, portrayed women as pitiful individuals, and in 7.6% women were degraded by negative comments.
Recent increase of publications on women's emancipation has positively contributed to the improvement and dissemination of feminist discourse. For example MONDAY, which is a monthly women's newspaper where the staff is also entirely female, published its first issue in April 1995, and defines itself as "a popular feminist periodical which supports everything which is positive for women and is against everything negative for women".
"There are Women" is the first documentary film that gives the historical background of the women's movement in Turkey. This film, which was directed by a woman, is about women's struggle to gain their rights from Tanzimat* and onwards. Also, the Turkish Radio and Television Institution (TRT) produced and broadcasted a documentary serial called "When the Doors Open" which considered the Turkish women's movement in parallel with movements elsewhere in the world. Moreover, non-governmental organizations are producing various films and television programs.
Objective: Increase the participation and access for women in decision-making and through the media and new communication technologies
By Government;
By Government and non-governmental organizations;
By Media Systems;
Develop, consistent with freedom of expression, regulatory mechanisms that promote balanced and positive images of women by the media and international communication systems and which promote increased participation by women in production and decision-making.
By non-governmental organizations and media professional associations;
Objective: Promote contemporary portrayals of women in the media and establish cooperation between Government, NGOs and media institutions for women
By Government;
By non-governmental organizations and relevant professional associations concerning the media;
Establish professional guidelines and determine sanctions concerning the image of women in the production of media material and marketing processes.